The paper offers a critical review of the so called "market transition
debate", using Nee's 1989 ASR article as its point of departure. It identifies
three major dimensions of the controversy: a) can market play an equalizing
role in an economic system? b) who benefits from the expansion of markets,
cadres or ordinary people? c) is the theory of markel transition teleological?
The main hypothesis of the paper is that at least as far as the first two
question is concerned the answer really should be "it depends". Both those
who accept markel transition theory and those who reject it make the error
or overgeneralizing írom their evidense. This paper instead suggests
that the task of social research is to identify under what circumstances,
what type and degree of market penetration produces equalizing effects,
what sort of markets benefit cadres or former cadres, and what sort of
markets were used by ordinary people to improve their life chances. The
paper offers a number of empirically testable hypotheses along these lines.
Bognár, Virág
Ideology and Utopia Shipwrecked. A Comparison of the German and
English Variants of Karl Mannheim's Ideology and Utopia
In the literature on Mannheim basically two views are current on how
the differences between the German and English variants of Ideology and
Utopia can be interpreted: a) the sociology of knowledge has undergone
a basic theoretical change, b) the English variam is an organic continuation
of the German original. The present paper gives a different answer. It
attempts to eliminate the 'shortcomings' of earlier literature by relying
among others on the 'list of differences' of more than one hundred pages
between the two textual variants, prepared by the author. One should not
see the radically changed theory of the sociology of knowledge in the English
variam, neither some kind of 'organic' continuation of the original theory,
but such a version in which some of the stylistic elements of thinking
in the German original have disappeared and the remaining ones have been
mixed with new ones; they create ambivalense and tension instead of creating
a similar, or radically different reading experience in the reader. With
such an open editing of the text, which characterises almost all of Mannheim's
writing, he apparently 'stands out' of the line of theoreticians. The origin
of the new elements is of two kinds: Mannheim wished to incorporate the
original theory of interpretation into a general theoretical framework
of sociology (of knowlendge). Its most important consequence was the separation
of interpretation by the sociology of knowledge from understanding. It
is impossible to extend the broadening of rationalisation so mich that
it should swallow even the sphere of the irrational. Ön the other
hand the experience of the victory of fascism and the Bence of the approaching
war had the greatest influence upon the changes of theory: it became obvious
that the sociology of knowledge was unable to say anything worthwhile about
authority, as it was too exposed in the face of it. The paper tries to
avoid 'labelling' and strives to interpret Mannheim's theory in its constant
change.
Utasi, Ágnes
Marriage, Divorce - Middle Class Identity: Practice and Attitudes
The middle classes possess a material and economic position and symbolic capital which is better than the average in society, thus usually they may shape their life style with greater autonomy if compared to those of lower status. At the same time they jealously guard their relatíve well being and highly appreciate security.
The paper studies whether the efforts of people living with a middle
class sense of identity in family and marriage are characterised by their
striving to achieve enhanced security? What is their opinion about living
together outside marriage and about divorce destabilising family and life
in marriage? The analysis confronts the opinion of middle class people
with the practice followed by them.
Fogarassy, Gabriella-Szántó, Zoltán
Privatization and the Tertius Gaudens
The study intends to contribute to the clarification of the interpersonal
preconditions of privatization processes. Its Basic aim si to show, typify,
and empirically illustrate the strategic interactions (status-seeking efforts,
bargaining and coalition formabon processes, ront- and intluence-seeking
activities, ete.), which - at least partly - could explain the fails or
successes of the different privatization attempts. The main emphasis is
put on the three-person relations. As a conceptual-theoretical starting
point Georg Simmel's and Theodore Caplow's classical ideas about triad
arc summerized, then different three-person interactions are presented,
which may substantially intluence he course of privatization. The empirical
illustration is based on a case study of our research on privatization
in Hungary.
Rácz, József
Doing nothing
Housing Estate and Slums Mentality
The author describes the new perspectives on research methods of ethnography. In his own research he conducted investigations among the 16-24-yean-old young people of a housing estate, where the field workers adopted the method of participant-observation.
In the present study the author describes the everyday activities of
the young people, their acts of violence (aggression agarost persons ad
objects), and the connection of the aggression with "doing nothing". Regarding
the group-formabon of the young the importance of two factors has been
pointed out: the importance of peer-field (which conception is different
from that of the peer-group): and the importance of slums mentality.
Gábrity, Molnár, Irén
The Sociological Aspects of the Emigration of Yugoslav Population
The emigration of Yugoslav population has been going on for three decades.
Its first wave when people were laking up temporary jobs in the developed
capitalist countries startod after 1965, when the socio-economic reform
was startod after World War II. The state wished to solve the problem of
agricultural overpopulation, unemployment and unskilled labour by opening
the borders. By the early eighties it was the migration of trained labour
and experts which became characteristic. The goal of migration was the
countries of Western and Northern Europe (the FRG, Austria and France).
By the late eighties it was economic migration. Now, in the nineties the
motivations of migration change: it has political as well as psychological
causes, the danger of war and military mobiliration, forced removals of
people from their homes give a ncw dimension to the emigration of Yugoslavs.
They go away in marser, young experts and entire families leave. In my
papot 1 have pointed out the characteristics and dimensions of economic
emigration, its motivations, the extent of adjustment to the new environment.